Skip to content
Shetler Fine Jewelers
Navigation menu
ENGAGEMENT & BRIDAL
SFJ Signature Bridal
Engagement Ring Settings
Women's Wedding Bands
Men's Wedding Bands
Diamonds
Diamond Search
The 4 C's of Diamonds
The Bridal Journey
Bridal Guide
Crafting Your Forever Ring
SHOP
Featured
New Arrivals
Vintage Finds
Shetler Collection
Our Curated Picks
Sale
Gift Cards
Categories
Necklaces
Gold Chains
Rings
Earrings
Earring Charms
Bracelets
Charms & Pendants
Watches
Diamond Essentials
Diamond Necklaces
Diamond Bracelets
Diamond Studs
Designers
Antonio Papini
Cicada
Eden Presley
EF Collection
Helena Rose
Jade Trau
JB Star
Jenna Blake
Jorge Adeler
Kwiat
Meira T.
Nouvel Heritage
Penny Preville
Single Stone
Spinelli Kilcollin
State Property
Temple St. Clair
Three Stories
Services
Concierge Services
Appointment Services
Custom Design Services
Appraisal Service
Fine Jewelry Guarantee
Precious Metals and Coins
Financing
Insurance
REPAIRS
EVENTS
Our Story
The Shetler Story
Testimonials
INFORMATION
FAQs
Blog
Gift Cards
CONTACT
Contact Us
Request an Appointment
Request an Engagement Ring Appointment
Login
Search
Cart
Close
ENGAGEMENT & BRIDAL
SHOP
Services
REPAIRS
EVENTS
Our Story
INFORMATION
CONTACT
ENGAGEMENT & BRIDAL
SFJ Signature Bridal
Engagement Ring Settings
Women's Wedding Bands
Men's Wedding Bands
Diamonds
Diamond Search
The 4 C's of Diamonds
The Bridal Journey
Bridal Guide
Crafting Your Forever Ring
SHOP
Featured
New Arrivals
Vintage Finds
Shetler Collection
Our Curated Picks
Sale
Gift Cards
Categories
Necklaces
Gold Chains
Rings
Earrings
Earring Charms
Bracelets
Charms & Pendants
Watches
Diamond Essentials
Diamond Necklaces
Diamond Bracelets
Diamond Studs
Designers
Antonio Papini
Cicada
Eden Presley
EF Collection
Helena Rose
Jade Trau
JB Star
Jenna Blake
Jorge Adeler
Kwiat
Meira T.
Nouvel Heritage
Penny Preville
Single Stone
Spinelli Kilcollin
State Property
Temple St. Clair
Three Stories
Services
Concierge Services
Appointment Services
Custom Design Services
Appraisal Service
Fine Jewelry Guarantee
Precious Metals and Coins
Financing
Insurance
Our Story
The Shetler Story
Testimonials
INFORMATION
FAQs
Blog
Gift Cards
CONTACT
Contact Us
Request an Appointment
Request an Engagement Ring Appointment
Cart
Your cart is empty
Three Stories
Sort by
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
39 products
Three Stories
Family Tree Azurite Locket Pendant
$8,680.00
Three Stories
Small Dragon Fly Earring Charms
$1,740.00
Three Stories
Prong Set Diamond Cross Studs
$1,480.00
Three Stories
Small Love Explosion Diamond Earring
$3,770.00
Three Stories
Double Sided Peacock Flip Ring
$4,975.00
Three Stories
Large Dragon Fly Emerald Top Switch Charm
$2,620.00
Three Stories
Classic Oval Pave Hoops
$1,700.00
Three Stories
Classic Bezel Set Pearl Bangle
$6,820.00
Three Stories
Medium Diamond Huggie Hoops
$2,820.00
Three Stories
Double Sided Colibri Top Switch Charms
$2,420.00
Three Stories
Classic Bezel Set Rainbow Sapphire Bangle
$7,230.00
Three Stories
Tell Your Story Zodiac Flip Ring
$6,075.00
Three Stories
Small Diamond Love Explosion Charms
$1,190.00
Three Stories
Classic Small Rectangular Diamond Hoops
$2,780.00
Three Stories
Love Always Rainbow Sapphire & Diamond Band
$1,960.00
Three Stories
Diamond Prong Small Engraved Hoops
$1,540.00
Three Stories
Classic Emerald and Diamond Baguette Bangle
$7,995.00
Three Stories
Classic High Polish Round Loopy Chain
$3,920.00
Three Stories
Prong Set Diamond Cross Top Switch Charm
$2,100.00
Three Stories
Emerald and Diamond Two-Sided Rectangular Hoops
$2,890.00
Three Stories
Make a Wish Small Crescent Moon and Star Charms
$1,320.00
Three Stories
Classic Metal Set Diamond Rectangular Hoops
$1,630.00
Three Stories
Classic Hammered Bezel Charms
$1,720.00
Three Stories
Ombre Dagger Earring Charms
$1,300.00
Three Stories
Sari Diamond Dagger Earring Charms
$1,680.00
Three Stories
Open Evil Eye Sapphire Earring Charms
$1,790.00
Three Stories
Classic Diamond Huggie Hoops
$1,480.00
Three Stories
Long Love Explosion Starburst Charms
$1,700.00
Three Stories
Diamondback Emerald Snake Hoops
$2,560.00
Three Stories
Cutout Elongated Diamond "V" Hoop Earrings
$3,700.00
Three Stories
Large Open Tree Of Life Pendant
$3,565.00
Three Stories
Radiant Peacock Fan Pendant
$7,220.00
Three Stories
Serpent Coil Wrap Around Flip Ring
$5,985.00
Three Stories
Small Wise Owl Earring Charms
$3,960.00
Three Stories
Sapphire and Diamond Peacock Eye Feather Bracelet
$7,645.00
Three Stories
Small Oval Graduated Diamond Huggie Hoops
$3,280.00
Three Stories
Double Sided Diamond, Emerald, and Ruby Serpent Necklace
$7,160.00
Three Stories
Show Your Love Continuous Turquoise Heart Bangle
$7,285.00
Three Stories
Ancient Balinese Emerald Door Pendant
$15,595.00