The Shetler Story
At Shetler Fine Jewelers, our story is one of passion, craftsmanship, and family. Founded 20 years ago by Michelle Shetler, the company was built on her vision of creating an exceptional jewelry experience—where timeless designs and meaningful relationships come together. Her commitment to excellence and personalized service laid the foundation for everything we do.
Over the years, Shetler Fine Jewelers has grown into a true family business. Michelle’s husband, Todd Shetler, joined the team, bringing his expertise in finance and operations to ensure the company’s continued success. Their daughter, Blake Shetler, followed in their footsteps, contributing her innovative approach to sales and serving as the Head of Marketing.
Together, we blend tradition and innovation, offering our clients not only exquisite jewelry but also an unparalleled level of care and service. At Shetler Fine Jewelers, we’re proud to be a family that helps you celebrate life’s most meaningful moments.
Shetler Fine Jewelers is a fine jewelry store offering the highest quality of customer service since our doors first opened in 2005. Home to an expertly curated assortment of exceptional fine jewelry, we boast a high standard of excellence for any budget.
In early 2021, Shetler Fine Jewelers acquired Medlar Jewel Masters resulting in the addition of two master jewelers and an onsite designer. Alongside the existing Shetler Fine Jewelers’ sales and design staff the acquisition created a combined fine jewelry experience spanning over 120 years.
The result is an end-to-end experience for clients and the ability to expertly manage every touch point in the custom jewelry process with improved efficiencies, and expanded offerings and skill sets.
expert advice. elevated service
Have a question? We're here to help!
Let us guide you in finding the perfect piece of jewelry for your special occasion.